Bridging the Policy Divide in the Never-Ending WOTUS Debate

Member and Industry News,

By Prianka Sharma, ARTBA

When you think of bridges, one of the first things that comes to mind is water. Bridges get you from one side of the water to the other. They remove the divide. They bring people, communities, and ideas together.

Ironically, the opposite is true for federal water policy, which for the better part of five decades has generated fierce legal challenges and policy debates. At the heart of the divisive topic is the 1972 Clean Water Act’s (CWA) definition of Waters of the United States (WOTUS) and words like “navigable waterways” and other water features. Whether these features fall under federal jurisdiction can determine if a project requires a federal permit and potentially mitigation. But unlike a bridge that facilitates connection, we could not be more divided on what the definition of WOTUS should be.

The CWA was meant to protect our nation’s navigable waters from pollution. Something we all want. But the vague wording left the definition up for interpretation. As a result, there have been four major Supreme Court rulings on the scope of WOTUS since its enactment 54 years ago, and there have been five “final” rules issued in just the past decade.

For bridge builders, this debate is more than an abstract legal argument. The river beneath a bridge may clearly fall under federal jurisdiction, but the wetlands, drainage ditches, and other water features surrounding a project can be much harder to classify. That uncertainty can affect permitting decisions, construction schedules, and project costs.

At the end of 2025, the Trump administration issued a proposed rule attempting to define key WOTUS terms, including “relatively permanent,” and “continuous surface connection.” The proposal contemplated the use of a “wet season” for determining if a water was relatively permanent. While ARTBA generally supported the wet season concept, many ambiguities remained regarding the treatment of regional variations, and how the agencies would standardize the use of tools and datasets to measure the “wet season” in various regional Army Corps districts.

In September, the administration issued a supplemental proposal with alternatives to the “wet season” concept. It defines “relatively permanent” as “perennial” waters with standing or continuously flowing water year-round under ordinary conditions, subject to limited exceptions.

This could draw a much brighter line and reduce additional obscurities, especially for the transportation construction industry whose roadside drainage features often only carry water during precipitation events. While this approach could bring us closer to regulatory clarity, whether it can provide lasting certainty remains to be seen.

Just as a bridge requires sound engineering to withstand the test of time, so too does a regulation. The Supreme Court's 2023 Sackett v. EPA decision provides a legal foundation for the agencies' most recent approach. The wording used by the Justices in that case track closely with the wording in the supplemental proposed rule.

Yet, the question remains: Will we ever see a durable regulatory definition of WOTUS that all sides can live with?

Building safe and efficient infrastructure that meets the nation’s needs and protecting the environment do not have to be mutually exclusive goals. There's nothing political about using a bridge. Hopefully we reach a point where the rules governing the waters beneath it are just as dependable as the bridge itself.

Prianka Sharma is ARTBA deputy general counsel and vice president for regulatory affairs.