Loudoun Supervisors Mandate PLAs on County Construction Projects of $40 Million and Above
On Thursday evening, November 5, the Loudoun County Board of Supervisors voted 7-2 to require Project Labor Agreements (PLAs) on all new county construction contracts and bids of $40 million or more. Projects below $40 million may also carry a PLA at the Board's discretion. The $40 million threshold was not developed by county staff; Chair Phyllis Randall confirmed from the dais that it came out of discussions with the unions, and Supervisor Juli Briskman added that she had also spoken with the unions and "they seem okay with it."
What the Board Approved
The Board Member Initiative, brought by Chair Randall and Vice Chair Michael Turner, directs staff to attach a PLA to any new county construction contract or bid of $40 million or more. A friendly amendment from Supervisor Briskman limited the mandate to new construction so that contracts already awarded are not reopened.
Several points from the meeting matter directly to VTCA members:
- Supervisor Caleb Kershner noted that no neighboring Northern Virginia jurisdiction applies its PLA policy to horizontal (road) projects and asked that they be removed from the motion. Chair Randall declined. Unless the Finance Committee narrows it, the mandate reaches highway and bridge work as well as buildings, parks and facilities.
- Key questions are still unanswered. County Administrator Tim Hemstreet told the Board that staff does not yet know how the Board would exercise its discretion on projects under $40 million, or whether the policy covers every type of construction. Those questions go to the Finance, Government Operations and Economic Development Committee next week, after the policy has already been adopted.
- No cost analysis. The Board item itself lists the fiscal impact as "unknown at this time."
The Board Heard From You
The several dozen emails our members sent to the Supervisors were acknowledged. Chair Randall said she read them and appreciated them, but called them "the same emails we got the last time," and said they had "slowed the process down and stopped it."
Supervisor Matthew Letourneau made the case our members have been making: the Board approved two pilot PLA projects in May specifically to measure bids, costs and schedules in Loudoun, and not a single six-month update has come back yet. "Don't do a pilot project if you intend to be impatient," he said, warning that the mandate will disrupt the county's Capital Improvement Program, raise prices, and shift work away from Virginia's workforce, roughly 95 percent of which is non-union. Supervisor Kershner agreed the Board was "jumping the gun." Vice Chair Turner said Letourneau's concerns resonated with him and asked whether the policy could be made contingent on the pilot results, but ultimately deferred to the Chair.
In the end, Chair Randall, Vice Chair Turner and five other Supervisors were determined to move forward without the benefit of staff input or the results of the pilots already underway. Chair Randall was direct about why: "Four years passing is unacceptable," she said, adding, "I am impatient."
This was not a victory. But the Chair's own frustration that four years of effort had not produced a PLA shows that our work to slow this down has had a real impact.
How We Got Here
- First pilot rescinded. The Board's first attempt, on the Government Center project, was rescinded after Virginians4Fairness (V4F) filed a protest over unfair competition. Staff sent the Supervisors a memo explaining why it could not go forward, and we are working to obtain a copy.
- Dulles runway protest won. Separately, we recently won a bid protest on the Dulles runway job.
Our efforts are paying dividends.
Thank You
Thank you for taking the time to write to the Loudoun Supervisors and to represent your firm and your employees, and thank you for your continued support of VTCA.